My UD Naked palette, purchased two years ago by a very naive and makeup-noob me....was fake.
I don't mean really, obviously, terribly fake. It was passable and while I sometimes had my doubts (like how its Half-baked was horrendous in comparison to my Naked 2 purchased at Sephora), I really enjoyed using it.
I hustled over to Sephora on the first day of the year and picked up a few things in order to tweak my routine. Unfortunately, Naked 1 was sold out. Then I went to Macy's begrudgingly and grabbed one.